Download Autonomy, Consent and the Law by Sheila A.M. McLean PDF

By Sheila A.M. McLean

Autonomy is frequently stated to be the dominant moral precept in sleek bioethics, and it's also vital in legislations. admire for autonomy is related to underpin the legislations of consent, that is theoretically designed to guard the fitting of sufferers to make judgements according to their very own values and for his or her personal purposes. The thought that consent underpins beneficent and lawful clinical intervention is deeply rooted within the jurisprudence of nations through the global. notwithstanding, Autonomy, Consent and the Law demanding situations the connection among consent principles and autonomy, arguing that the very nature of the criminal procedure inhibits its skill to recognize autonomy, in particular in situations the place sufferers argue that their skill to behave autonomously has been lowered or denied because of the withholding of data which they'd have desired to obtain.

Sheila McLean extra argues that the bioethical debate in regards to the real nature of autonomy – whereas wealthy and challenging – has had little if any effect at the legislations. utilizing the alleged contrast among the individualistic and the relational versions of autonomy as a template, the writer proposes that, whereas it would be assumed that the model ostensibly most well-liked via legislations – approximately corresponding to the individualistic version – will be transparently and continually utilized, actually courts have vacillated among the 2 to accomplish policy-based goals. this is often highlighted by means of exam of 4 particular parts of the legislations which such a lot comfortably lend themselves to attention of the applying of the autonomy precept: specifically refusal of life-sustaining therapy and assisted demise, maternal/foetal concerns, genetics and transplantation.

This e-book can be of significant curiosity to students of scientific legislation and bioethics.

Show description

Read Online or Download Autonomy, Consent and the Law PDF

Similar health & medical law books

Law and human genetics: regulating a revolution

This factor addresses conceptual, moral, political and sensible concerns confronting the legislations within the face of the genetic revolution.

Contemporary issues in healthcare law and ethics

Modern concerns in Healthcare legislation and Ethics, Fourth version, examines an important criminal and moral concerns in healthcare and provides crucial info that can assist you discover ways to establish and take on power felony difficulties. This completely revised version comprises new details and vast updates on subject matters reminiscent of: The cheap Care Act (ACA the USA perfect court docket s judgements on physician-assisted suicide, the legal responsibility of wellbeing and fitness plans, and late-term abortion felony and moral concerns concerning the ACA birth control mandate The high-profile Terri Schiavo case regarding termination of lifestyles help The HIPAA privateness Rule and its impression on digital future health documents scientific malpractice reform and the reporting of clinical blunders New to this variation are end-of-chapter actions and dialogue inquiries to facilitate lecture room discussions.

After we die : the life and times of the human cadaver

What is going to turn into of our earthly is still? What occurs to bodies in the course of and after a few of the kinds of cadaver disposal on hand? Who controls the destiny of human continues to be? What felony and ethical constraints practice? criminal pupil Norman Cantor offers a image, informative, and unique exploration of those questions.

Extra info for Autonomy, Consent and the Law

Sample text

For Manson and O’Neill the real problem with the individualistic account is that: If individual autonomy is seen as fundamental to ethics, but merely as a matter of choice, then the only permissible restrictions on choice will be those required to protect others’ individual autonomy. All choices that leave others’ autonomy intact – however bizarre, however self-destructive, however offensive, however degrading – will be permissible, and restrictions on them will be unacceptable. 105 Isaiah Berlin agrees that this cannot be allowed to stand.

108 One obvious attraction of the relational model, therefore, is the sense of unity that it brings to the human enterprise. Freedom arguably becomes 105 106 107 108 Manson, N C, O’Neill, O, Rethinking Informed Consent in Bioethics, Cambridge University Press, 2007, at p 20. Berlin, I, ‘Two Concepts of Liberty’, in Berlin, I, Four Essays on Liberty, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1961, at p 170. Pellegrino, E D, Thomasma, D C, ‘The Conflict Between Autonomy and Beneficence in Medical Ethics: Proposal for a Resolution’, Journal of Contemporary Health Law and Policy, 3(23), 1987: 23–46, at p 35.

105 Isaiah Berlin agrees that this cannot be allowed to stand. While freedom of choice and action are central to what it is to be autonomous, nonetheless ‘[t]he extent of a man’s, or a people’s, liberty to choose to live as they desire must be weighed against the claims of many other values, of which equality, or justice, or happiness, or security, or public order are perhaps the most obvious examples. ’106 On this view, it is not merely the harm principle that can legitimately limit individual choice – more abstract considerations, such as justice, should also have a place in the evaluation of the quality of the decision.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.09 of 5 – based on 47 votes